I've been rotating these 3 products for weeks now and decided to make a quick post on it. Since my skin is warm/deep tan/medium dark silver or white eyeliner can appear too harsh on me and really wanted something more with a kick in it instead of the cream/crème color eyeliner/eyeshadow.

Anywho, I rediscover in my stash my three now "staples of the moment" gold eyeliner. Each are gold, but with a hint of a hue.
MAC Butternutty (more of a pink hue to it)
NYX Velvet (brown hue to it)
Estee Lauder Sand Shimmer (peach hue to it)